Hi all...
I've purchased a 1BR from Goldcrest Smart City, and after I made 3 payments I've received the Sales & Purchase Agreement with some clauses that I refuse completely, so I'm thinking of canceling the reservation of the apartment, the reservation form states that in case of canceling the reservation it will cause for the forfeiture of the booking amount, does the booking amount include all the payments that I've made or is it only the 5% reservation amount? and if it's only the reservation amount how may I request for the rest payment?
Smart City Contract
Can you please make reference to the specific clauses. I too have bought in Smart City, but I haven't received my contract yet. I would like to know what you are thinking is a problem so I can bring it to their attention and see if I can get any changes made.
The problems
Hi smitty...
Here are some of the issues that concerns me (especialy #5,8,9,11 & 12) and the letter I've send them :-
"Dear Sir...
I've contacted you earlier this morning in regards to some issues I have about the SPA you've sent for me last week, and it was kind of you to tell me to send any requests or questions via email instead of me coming from Abu Dhabi, therefor I'm sending this email pointing out the issues I'm talking about.
1- In page (2),it doesn't mention the view even though one of the most important elements that I based my selection of the unit on was it's location and the view it locks at. And can you please point out which of the 8 towers is IB110,because the towers in the master plan starts from (IB01-IB08).
2-In page(5),clause (5),can you please clarify what are the adjustments and how will these adjustments affect the total price?
3- In page(5),clause(7.7),I believe that as the Vendor request that the Purchaser protect the Vendors rights when selling the unit,the Vendor vise versa should protect the Purchaser rights when selling the land/development to a third party by stating that the third party will carry out all the responsibilities and agreements set between the Vendor and Purchaser,and the Vendor should assure that the Third Party acknowledges by writing that such party will be bound by the rules of this agreement.
4- In page(6),clause (9),in the event of dispute there should be a professional UNBIAS party to make the final decision, and I don't believe that the Vendor's Architect should be that party.
5- In page (7),clause (11.3),again one of the main selling points of the project was that the Master Developer(i.e. BONYAN) GUARANTIES that in case the government or concerned authority were unable/failed to provide electricity then they (BONYAN) will, and based on that I believe that the part of the clause saying "under its sole discretion choose" should be changed to "Guaranties".
6- In page (7),clause (12.2.2),why should I(Purchaser) pay the next installment if the next Purchaser is bound to pay it as stated in clause(12.1)? and as explained to me by the sales executive which sold me the Unit, the 2% transfer fee is from the Unit's initial selling price and not from the resale price.
7- In page (7),clause (12.3),again as long as the affiliated company is bound by the rules and agreements set between the Vendor & the Purchaser.
8- In page (7),clause (13.1)&(13.2),in their current forms they give the Vendor all the right and strips the Purchaser from all of his rights, I believe that the contract in all it's clauses should protect both parties rights and not only one of them.I believe a paragraph such as "and any colors,materials,finishes,equipment,fixtures and specifications that might be changed,varied or modified would be the same or better quality than the originals", and the Vendor should specify (as all the respectful developers in their SPAs do) all the finishing materials, fixtures, and equipments with their brand names in schedules attached to this SPA.
9- In page( 8 ),clause (14),I believe that fortifying all the payments made by the Purchaser as liquidated damages is not fair and a percentage of the payments would be more than fair for the Vendor could sell the Unit again,and in it's current form the Purchaser could have paid like 85% of the total price and for some reason out of the Purchaser's will, one of the payments get delayed,that will strip him/her of everything paid before??!!
10-In page(9),clause (16),the Vendor should do all in his/her power and use all legal means to solve issues mentioned in clauses (16.2-16.5), otherwise the Vendor could use the clauses(16.2-16.5) as an excuse to delay the completion date.
11- In Schedule (4),Features list,the Vendor should specify that (LG) is the provider of the features listed as (LG) was the brand sold to the Purchaser at the time of reservation.
12- In the SPA the Vendor should provide a Schedule of Finishes and Materials that the Vendor intends to use in the Unit (i.e. type of doors,windows,flooring.etc)
13- In page (13),(Power of the association),it should mention the amount of the membership fee and the annual maintenance fee/sqft. or the clauses should state that the fees fixed will be reasonable and compatible with market prices for similar projects.
I believe that clearing these issues will be of great importance for both parties for it will protect the Purchaser's rights and interests (same as the Vendor's), and it will boost the confidence in the Vendor's commitment to provide quality products and excellent projects in the current market situation."
I hope this will be of help to you and other purchasers.
Regards
Cancellation of Booking
I've purchased a 1BR in Emirates City, and after I made 5/6 payments I've received the Sales & Purchase Agreement with some clauses that I refuse completely, so I'm thinking of canceling the reservation of the apartment, the reservation form states that in case of canceling the reservation it will cause for the forfeiture of the booking amount, i am ready to pay AED 10000 paid against booking. But developer is asking to pay 15% of the total value of the flat mentioned in the contract which is not signed yet due to some unacceptable clause.
How to resolve this ? Can you please guide
unacceptable clauses
it is another fraud
we'll see contracts after we paid!
what we do if we dont agree with some clauses
if you know a lawer please talk with him , what he says
refund
Dear All,
myself and my friend is also in shame problem to get the money back however giga group is not willing too..
lets be together and fight our case..my number is 0507243691 my friend no 050 5593421 mukherjee_rana@yahoo.com
i am fine loosing 5% however donot want to loose any more..
is the project getting delayed?? I havent signed the contract yet...
have you referred the matter
have you referred the matter to arra yet, they may be able to assist
Smart Towers
What I have come to know from market sources is that entire Ain City Development under which Smart City project used to exist has been cancelled for good. I have been after the Developers for over a year to canel my booking request by forfieting initial deposit of 5% and refunding the remaining amount.
However, I have been constanty adivsed throughout this period that the Developers have been advised by the regulatory Authorities (ARRA) not to cancel any reservations until the registration formatlities with ARRA are completed.
In this regard, I have also approached ARRA where I was told that ARRA has not advised any developer to hold on to cancellation request. Infact ARRA would not intervene in the cancellation request until the project is registered with them.
I think we all need to gather to collectively take action against the developer.
what is -after 30 days payment??
as per the giga group "'after 30 days'payment is considers as booking amount??? is it true??? in reciept its written on after 30 days payment nothing is written and booking amount...
Lets get together to get our money back from Star Giga
Dear all,
Please call me if you wish to get along to get the money back..they should only deduct the 5% not 10%...
Any update with construction process???? if it delayed do we get our money back???
Please call me if need to go to star giga office 050 7243691/050 5593421
thanks
hi rana
Hi rana
what they told you about this
Im with you
I’m one of the GCD3 buyers. I also want to cancel my reservation .I still did not sign my contract. The main reason is the delay in contract processing in ETA as a well-known issue. But now I am refusing to do that because the payment plan has been changed and they promised completion date has been postponed to two year after construction commencement which is not confirmed.
As the payment plan was the sole thing that we had chance to see at the booking time and we signed the booking agreement based on that. So basically we are not in the stage to complain about the contract clauses but we have to insist to cancel the reservation because of the changing in construction schedule.
i havent trust to them
they dont reply to emails and i dont send them even one penny to this dead desert
Reservation form is not a CONTRACT
Dear All
seems that we are all in the same position. So here are my comments hope we can all agree on similar approach. email me we can discuss each point in detail
1- You should approach ARRA right away and file a case with them against your developer.
2- Your reservation form is NOT a contract, so the 30% lose your money in dubai is not applicable to us, although your developer would like you to think that it is.
3- if your reservation form say 5%, or 10%, that thats all they should get, however, you should get this amount back as interest since developer has been keeping your money.
4- the clauses in the SPA are completely not acceptable to anyone, dont sign!!
5- if ARRA turn out to be on the developers side, you will need a lawyer and go to court. Start looking for a lawyer, you will not find one in ajman, however, dubai has plenty. Before you release your case details, make sure the lawyer is not working for your developer!
email me if you like to discuss.
HIRE A LAWYER
Dear all
I have already appointed a lawyer and we're preparing a case against Goldcrest Properties, the reservation form clearly states that on cancellation of the reservation only the booking amount will be forfeited, when I called GIGA Group and tried to solve the issue friendly their answer was that the booking amount includes the (After 30 days Payment)... and when I send them a letter to request my payments and canceling the reservation their answer was that they will not entertain any UNILATERAL cancellation and if I continue with my request it will cause of the forfeiture of all my payments???!!!!... at that point I appointed a lawyer and they clarify many issues to me:-
1- As long as I haven't signed the Sales & Purchase agreement,then the only law binding us is the reservation form clauses.
2- As it clearly states that the Booking amount is the amount to be forfeited then it does not include(After 30 days payment) because it's a PAYMENT!!!!
3- They advised me that if we took it to court the developer will try to claim the payments as to cover the losses they suffer after all the work they have done(i.e. Launching fees,Architects & consultants fees,construction costs ...etc.),all of those will be of no effect but the construction cost,so as long as they haven't started construction then we're in a better situation, so the faster we proceed to court the better.
Of course I've stopped giving them payments since Dec. 2008,but through that period they keep sending me letters requesting for payments,the first ones clearly states that if I didn't pay within 20 days then their will be a 500 AED fine for every day after, but after 2 months they send another letter requesting for the same payment with the same amount......and now after 4 months they sent another one just adding the next payment amount to the one before WITH NO THREATS OF FINES.....
Any one who wants to join me in going to court in order to get back our money Please don't hesitate to call me 0505316553, or call my lawyer ALRUKN AND ASSOCIATES 04-2276655 ask for Mr. Abdu Alselawi, their fees will be 5-10% of the amount of money you want back (Not the Unit price) ..... lets get together and build a case against GIGA Group.
Law
The law regarding reservation and purchase agreement may not be as simple as you think. The contract may be cancellable in the first 30 days but after that time and if you started and continued to make installment payments, would indicate your intention to agree with the main contract of purchase.
interesting point but what
interesting point but what if the developer delayed the contract beyond the 30days, infact in some cases i know of it was months before people got their contracts...... what of all the bullying / misleading by agents and/or the developer in making people pay ... i'm sure their is plenty of victims out their who can testify to these facts .....
ajmanman please keep us updated with your progress......
agree
Ashor
I think probably Mr. reality man is a developer rep of some sort. Dont listen to them, I am doing the same thing you are doing. All we have is a reservation form, which is not equal to SPA, not binding, on the contrary of what your developer would like you to think. To me, the reservation form is just booking and getting a slot in the pipeline, but before signing the contract, nothing matters. in a more lawful environment, you should have been able to get your money back by now, me and my lawyer are asking for 12% interest from the developer for him keeping my money although I sent him a clear cancellation to the reservation form.
you should do the same, get the 12%, google dubai and you will find a judge just awarded 9% interest to an investor where the developer kept his money unlawfully. Similar to our situation, if your going to court and your paying fees, it should be the developer either paying for your lawyer fees, or you getting interest on your stolen money.
oh no!
My secret identity has been discovered! Yes I work for the developers.
Why would it take you 6 months to change your mind and after all those installments. My point is a contract does not need signing when you have shown your agreement and intentions by continually paying.
I'm with you
I never signed contract , even i didnt sign reservation form
i sent them 8 months ago about return my money but they dont reply to me anymore
i want with you in court to get my money back with interest
here is my email:
arest77@imap.cc
Where have you reached?
Hi ajmanflat...
Can you tell me where have you reached in this matter? I mean have you already submit the case to the courts,or you're in negotiations with your developer? what is your case exactly?
Smartcity Project by Giga
Hi people,
I am afraid what Mr. reality-man is saying is bitter for us investors in this project but absolutely right.
The developer in this case has 101 excuses not to refund our money even if we never signed the Contract. I too have not signed it and what is more stupid, have paid 20% of the price!!!
Now, I wish to believe what the lawyer is telling Mr. ajmanflat but my experience with lawyers in UAE (and it is a considerable experience as I, myself am property management) tells me that the lawyer is just giving false hopes and has no solid ground to base his postive outlook upon. Most unfortunate is the fact that even if we are legally right to demand our moeny back, the developer can make us wait for years wihtout getting into any trouble!!
Best thing to do at the moment is to join hands, gather as many investors as possible, lets say worth one whole tower and make a collective demand. They have not been able to sell the other 5 towers till now and would be in no position to ignore so many investors.
What do you say?
Smart Towers Giga group
tomorrow few of us - investors are going to Sheikh Zayed office at 1330 hrs...if u wish to come call me 050 7243691...
guys, did you know that
guys, did you know that smart city owners are given an alternative Dubai property now a days? I am sure it is one way of saying,, that they are not looking at refund of money at all, and will blame it on ARRA and its obligations. dubai is good option if received at the right price, atleast money will be safe.